Email archiving software compared (free, open source, MailStore alternatives)

What are the alternatives to MailStore Server?

Free email archiving software exists, but “free” means something different for each product. Piler is free but you have to run it yourself. MailStore Home and Benno’s community edition are free only under conditions. The archiving features of Microsoft 365 belong to the platform and are not a separate archiving product.

The figures come from the vendor pages, retrieved on 12 November 2026.

ProductLicence and priceDeployment and sources
MailStore ServerOne-off payment from €295.00 plus VAT: Starter Kit for up to 5 users, including 12 months of update and support serviceWindows 11 and Windows Server 2016 to 2025, virtual machines included; Exchange Server, Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, IMAP and POP3, PST, EML
MailStore Homefree of charge for private use at homeWindows 10 and 11, archive stored locally or on a USB drive; Outlook, Thunderbird, PST, EML
Piler, Open Source EditionSource code under GPL v3, “Free forever” according to the vendor, help through the communityyour own server, installation guide for Ubuntu; SMTP, Office 365, Google, import from EML, MBOX, IMAP, POP3
Benno MailArchivSelf-hosting from €80 per year for 5 mailboxes, cloud from €4.50 per month including 10 GB of archive storage, basis of the price not stated (net); community edition for non-commercial use onlyLinux, not Windows; VM or Docker, or cloud in Germany; Exchange, Microsoft 365, Zimbra, Kerio
Microsoft 365: archive mailbox and retention policiesPrice not stated on the pages retrieved; the 3 TB increase applies to certain licences, including E5, A5 and G5 and Purview suitesCloud (Exchange Online); retention also covers SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams

Is MailStore Home an option for a company?

No. According to the vendor, MailStore Home is “free of charge for private use at home”, and for use in companies the page points to MailStore Server. Home runs on Windows 10 and 11 and keeps the archive locally.

MailStore Server, by contrast, runs without an extra web server such as IIS and needs no external database, says the vendor. A Starter Kit for five users costs from €295.00 plus VAT, and further users are licensed on top.

What does Piler offer, and what do you have to provide yourself?

Piler comes as an Open Source Edition and as an Enterprise Edition with support. The free edition runs on a single server.

  • Licence: According to the licence file in the GitHub repository, the source code is under the GNU General Public License, version 3.
  • Features: archiving through a built-in SMTP server, retention and exclusion rules, legal hold, full-text search, deduplication, AES-256 encryption, sign-in through AD or LDAP.
  • Deployment: The documentation lists at least 2 CPU cores, 2 GB of RAM and 200 GB of disk. Installation involves MariaDB, Manticore Search, nginx and PHP, among others.
  • Enterprise Edition: According to the comparison table, Teams archiving, a REST API, multiple nodes, S3 storage and support with guaranteed response times exist only there. Pricing is on request.

When is Benno MailArchiv worth a look?

The vendor offers Benno MailArchiv as a self-hosted version and as a cloud service. Both prices are net.

  • Self-hosting: an annual subscription from €80 for 5 mailboxes. The right of use is unlimited in time, the vendor says, even without valid maintenance.
  • Deployment: on hardware, virtualised (VMware, Proxmox, KVM, XEN, Hyper-V) or in Docker containers. According to the vendor, Benno does not run on Windows.
  • Cloud: According to the product page, Benno Cloud Enterprise costs from €4.50 per month including 10 GB of archive storage, in two data centres in Germany. What the price refers to, such as mailbox or organisation, the product page does not say; the home page also lists “from €0.12 per GB/month”.
  • Community edition: “Open Benno MailArchiv” needs no licence key. According to the vendor it is for non-commercial use only, has no user separation, is limited to three tenants and is “not suitable for legally compliant archiving” (the vendor’s wording, translated).

Are the archiving features of Microsoft 365 enough?

Microsoft describes two building blocks. The archive mailbox adds space: once turned on, it provides up to 100 GB of extra storage, and up to 1.5 TB with auto-expanding archiving. The default policy moves items that are two years or older into the archive mailbox.

For certain licences Microsoft raises the ceiling to 3 TB, including Office 365 and Microsoft 365 E5, A5 and G5 and Purview suites. The page says the rollout was to begin in mid-October 2026 and finish by late October. For licences outside this list the limit stays at 1.5 TB.

Retention policies define how long content is kept and when it is deleted; content stays in its original location. If someone edits or deletes it, Exchange mailboxes keep a copy in the Recoverable Items folder, if the setting retains content (retain-only or retain and then delete). With delete-only settings the user can permanently delete the item there; otherwise it is deleted after 14 days. The three Microsoft pages retrieved name no way to export mailboxes into another archive format.

Which criteria help you choose?

The vendors name different mechanisms; compare them one by one.

  1. Deployment: MailStore Server runs on Windows, Piler is installed on Ubuntu according to its guide, Benno runs on Linux. As a service there are MailStore Cloud (monthly subscription, through partners and in OpenText’s German data centre, according to the vendor), Benno Cloud and Microsoft 365. Without a Linux server, you can rule out self-hosted Piler and Benno.
  2. Tamper protection: MailStore names SHA hash values over the email content and internal AES256 encryption. Piler names digital signing and verification. Benno creates a SHA-256 checksum per email and checks it every time a message is displayed. With settings that retain content, Microsoft keeps copies in the Recoverable Items folder. Ask about the mechanism, not the buzzword.
  3. Export route: MailStore exports to standard formats and can add a cryptographic signature to exported emails. Piler exports to EML. For Benno and Microsoft, the pages retrieved name none. Test an export before you commit: the archive usually outlives the product.
  4. Search and access: MailStore offers an Outlook add-in and Web Access, Piler and Benno a web interface, Microsoft access through Outlook and Outlook on the web.

For retention duties, GoBD and GDPR, see Email archiving: legal duty, GoBD and GDPR. For the MailStore variants Server, Cloud and Service Provider Edition, see MailStore Server, Cloud or SPE.

Nexilon is a MailStore Authorized Partner.

Sources

Let's talk

Free initial consultation - no sales pitch, just an honest assessment.

Request a consultation →